RIGHTS AND CONSERVATION
An ILC Africa learning exchange
2-6 October, 2023
Bringing together almost 200 people from across Africa under the general theme "rights and conservation", the learning exchange reinforced the importance of people-centred conservation and strategies to ensure communities are directly involved in conservation efforts.
Summary Report
This report was put together from notes taken by several participants in the learning exchange.
READ MORE
180
Participants
4
Field Visits
100 people participated in our field visits to the Ogiek, Endorois, Masaai Mara, and Masaai Natasha communities and 180 people attended the opening ceremony on Kenya Day.
The Naboisho conservancy
Koyiaki campus
Wildlife tourism college of Maasai Mara Mara
The Naboisho conservancy is a 50,000 acre community wildlife conservation area on the border of the Masai Mara Reserve.
The community conservancy concept is part of a new model of tourism designed to create a mutually beneficial partnership between the Maasai and the tour operators: instead of buying land off the Maasai, the land is leased for the purpose of wildlife conservation and local communities can enjoy a guaranteed annual income while retaining ownership of the land.
Tourism generates employment too as all camp staff, guides and conservancy rangers are drawn from the families of the Maasai landowners. Finally, the removal of all sedentary homesteads and livestock bomas within the conservancy allows grass and vegetation to recover from overgrazing.
The Maasai's vision at the Naboisho conservancy is to build a sustainable future by bringing communities, land and wildlife conservation together, where all can flourish.
Now that’s what we’re talking about!
- Community-led conservation - the conservancy in Naboisho has not only achieved conservation goals but has also improved the livelihoods of 700 families who have pooled their land together to form the conservancy.
- Heritage preservation - by incorporating traditional knowledge and practices into the conservation and management of the land in Naboisho, the Maasai have managed to strike a balance between conservation and the preservation of their way of life.
- Land tenure security - the provision of 25-year-long leases for individual landowners within the conservancy in Naboisho showcases a long-term commitment to both conservation and community development which provides security for landholders.
- Education and empowerment - the support provided for education through the school for youth, such as bursaries for 2,400 students secures a brighter future for the community and also ensures that traditional knowledge and conservation practices are passed down to the next generation.
- Economic empowerment - the employment of 500 people, with 80% of them being from the local community, showcases the economic empowerment that can result from community-led conservation as in Naboisho.
- Balancing livestock and wildlife - the allocation of 70% of the land in the conservancy for grazing demonstrates a successful balance between wildlife conservation and traditional livestock practices. This approach mitigates conflicts and ensures the sustainability of both wildlife and livestock in the region.
- Predator compensation - the provision of compensation for livestock losses due to predators is a practical solution to conflicts between wildlife conservation and the economic interests of the Maasai community, providing a means of addressing these issues without resorting to violence against wildlife.
- Strategies, such as litigation, advocacy, and mass action, initiated mainly by young students as land defenders related to internal land conflicts in the Maji Moto community and leading to a long and challenging struggle for justice that finally had successful outcomes.
The Naboisho Conservancy showcases a successful model of community-led conservation. Over 700 Maasai landowners have come together to collectively manage the conservancy, pooling their land parcels under common land use plans.
Over time, they managed to build a more resilient community out of the several income-generating activities linked to the conservancy management plan.
This is Dorine Kumum, a guide at @Naboishoconservancy. Most of the guides have graduated from the Koiyaki Guiding School where local Maasai get access to education in guiding and conservation.
The school offers 18-months training courses for students to prepare for the Kenyan National Guide Certificate Exam. Since it opened in 2005, more than 170 students have graduated, a considerable proportion of whom have been women. Each class has approximately 30 students, of which at least 1/3 are women: an important precedent for gender equality in higher education.
The Endorois Community, Baringo county
Traditionally pastoralists, the Endorois Indigenous Peoples have transitioned to agropastoralism to engage in farming activities around Lake Bogoria.
Over the past few years, the community has been working towards establishing registered wildlife conservancies to ensure sustainable management of resources
The Endorois' struggle for justice, transition from traditional pastoralism to agropastoralism, religious and cultural practices and the deep connection the community with Lake Bogoria plays an integral role in their identity.
In February 2010, the African Commission on Human and Peoples' Rights (ACHPR) recommended that the Kenyan government recognise the Endorois community's ancestral land rights, restitute their lands, and provide compensation. Despite this, little has been done to implement the recommendations, which has lead to severe poverty, illiteracy and poor health for many community members.
- Those who started these struggles are now getting old and called strongly for the younger generation to step up and take it forward. The disconnection of younger community members from land struggles is a global issue for active and creative engagement.
- The community had high expectations that their visitors would be able to help and ensure they finally received justice, and the visit provided a renewed sense of hope, as well as of being visible and recognised.
- The impact of the climate crisis was visible and very clear to the community itself, with rising waters in the lake displacing community members to bare and steep land.
- The cultural and religious importance of resources is critical to understanding the Endorois. “Sukta” means “sacred space” and has enormous significance to the community. This cultural attachment has contributed to the spring's preservation over the years.
- While many more technical solutions could be found to maximise the benefits of the spring, it is critical to be led by the community’s priorities and the limited resources available to take small, achievable steps.
- By fostering a sense of ownership and encouraging community participation, the participatory project around the spring has ensured sustainability.
- There is a need to work together to identify how to move from theory - in the Lake Bogoria case, from a Court Judgement and international frameworks - to action.
- Solidarity with other indigenous communities facing similar struggles is needed.
We spoke with Irene Mukalo from Resource Conflict Institute about the Sukta Community Water Spring project, a perfect example of community-led resource management.
💧The Sukta Spring has played a historically crucial role in ensuring water availability during dry periods while also holding cultural and religious importance for the local community. It currently provides water to 2,100 households and over 15,000 heads of cattle.
We spoke with Christine Kandie, Executive Director of Endorois Women Empowerment Network, empowering women and people with disability in the community.
The Narasha and Ogiek communities
The Maasai community in Narasha has struggled against repeated forced eviction and involuntary resettlement due to the establishment of a National Park and the development and expansion of geothermal projects on their ancestral lands.
The lack of consultation and consideration of the impact on the Maasai's pastoralist livelihoods has resulted in the reduction of grazing land suitable for their livestock and in an overall negative impact on livelihoods and the environment.
The community is finally fighting back demanding for adequate compensation: the Maasai in Narasha have effectively preserved their cultural values and traditions including religious events and their traditional hierarchical structure.
Promises made after the 2014 evictions remain unfulfilled to this date and the situation is precarious. Some have been relocated to areas that are inaccessible, have a poor soil, are prone to land-slides and provide little or no services. The houses are also poorly constructed and the newly built school is subject to frequent flooding.
Most importantly, the relocated community lacks ownership over housing and territory. External interventions such as the institution of reserves and protected areas, electricity plants and so on represent a constant threat to the stability and well-being of the community.
- A secure space is essential for the community's survival, as most households find themselves vulnerable.
- Establish a robust organisational mechanism within the community to create a powerful advocacy group.
- Conduct a comprehensive study to produce a compelling advocacy document.
- Advocate for the respect of human rights and hold states accountable for their commitments
The Ogiek of Mau consist of around 40,000 members and inhabit the Mau Forest which extends across different counties. For hundreds of years they have relied on the forest for their livelihood, their food, their medicine.
In May 2017 the African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights recognized Ogiek people's property rights and the relevance of their cultural heritage. This ruling emphasised the role of Indigenous Peoples in conservation and found the Kenyan government guilty of violating Ogiek's territorial rights entitling the Ogiek to restitution and compensation.
Despite winning their case, many Ogiek remain without access to the forest. Younger Ogiek for example have never lived there and have adapted to a different way of life.
- The African Court ruling confirming Indigenous Peoples’ rights of the Ogiek is a significant milestone but it needs to be actively implemented.
- The successful collaboration between the Kenya Forest Service and Ogiek communities shows the potential of breaking down barriers for productive partnerships.
- The role of youth and women in Ogiek's reforestation initiative highlights the significance of inter-generational skill transfer and the key role that each plays in sustainable forest management.
- It is important to recognize the value of Ogiek’s tree growing system which goes beyond initial planting. It shows their commitment to the long-term health of the Ogiek forest.
- Agroforestry, including bee-keeping, provides alternative livelihoods complementary to wild species. Promotion and funding of agroecology practices are crucial for ensuring food security, and continued community empowerment is essential for sustained forest protection.
- Challenges from “non-Ogiek” settlements in the forest require sensitivity to resolve potential conflicts promptly.
- The forest is not just a “resource”, it is Ogiek’s home, life, culture, and identity. Ogiek are hunters and gatherers. They know their forest better than anyone. Deforestation for agriculture only happens when other means of livelihood no longer are available
- Recognizing and addressing issues related to public land use can reduce conflicts and land tenure insecurity.
- Access to carbon credits – could possibly be a source of income for these communities, if their rights are respected and the conditions are fair and just